How Are RSUs Taxed?

A Guide to Restricted Stock Units for Young Professionals

Restricted stock units are one of the most common forms of equity compensation at established companies, and many times the most misunderstood. The confusion costs people real money every year.

The short answer: RSUs are taxed as ordinary income on the day they vest, based on the share price that day, whether or not you sell anything. Your employer withholds federal tax at a flat 22% (37% if > $1 million in wages), and the difference could become a surprise bill at tax time if not acknowledged. For many people, selling shares at vesting and moving on may be the right though specific situations may dictate alternative actions.

What actually happens on your vest date?

A vest date is a taxable event. Not a milestone, not a paper gain a taxable event that behaves exactly like a bonus.

Here is an Example:
Say 100 shares vest and the stock closes at $100. That's $10,000 of ordinary income added to your W-2 for the year, taxed at your regular income rates plus Social Security and Medicare. It doesn't matter whether you sell, hold, or forget the shares exist.

This is also why there's no waiting for a better price. The tax is locked to the vest-date value permanently. If the stock drops to $50 next month, you still owe tax on $10,000 and now you hold $5,000 of stock. That tax fundamental is likely the most important thing to understand about RSUs.

What is sell-to-cover, and does it cover enough?

Most companies handle withholding automatically by selling a portion of your vesting shares and sending the proceeds to the IRS. In the example above, a portion of your 100 shares might be sold to cover the IRS bill, leaving you with a number closer to 70 or 80.

But...

The IRS requires employers to withhold on supplemental income bonuses, vested stock, commissions at a flat 22% federal rate, rising to 37% only above $1 million in supplemental wages for the year. But 22% is just a default, not a calculation of what you owe. If your salary plus vesting stock puts you in the 24%, 32%, or 35% bracket, your employer under-withheld anywhere between 2 to 13 percentage points.

On $10,000 of vested stock, that 2-13% gap in withholding may be substantial. When you factor in much larger RSU’s the number is even greater. On $100,000 of vesting stock, 13% is a $13,000 surprise tax bill. State tax withholding often follows the same flat-rate logic, so the gap can widen further.

How do you close the withholding gap?

Here are three approaches you could take:

Adjust your W-4. Line 4(c) lets you request extra withholding from each paycheck. This is the cleanest fix because withholding counts as if it were paid evenly across the year, even if you add it in November.

Make a quarterly estimated payment. Pay the shortfall directly after a large vest. Straightforward, but timing matters as payments are credited to the quarter you make them.

Set the cash aside and pay in April. Fine if you're disciplined, with one caveat: if you underpay significantly through the year, the IRS can charge an underpayment penalty.
Can’t pay today?: You avoid underpayment penalty by paying at least 90% of this year's tax, or 100% of last year's total tax 110% if your prior-year income was above $150,000. Hitting one of those marks means you can owe them in April but still avoid the penalty.

Should you sell your RSUs?

Answer: For many young professionals, selling at vest may be an optimal strategy.

This resists intuition, so here's the logic. You've already paid full income tax on the vest-date value. Holding gives you no tax advantage you wouldn’t find elsewhere. It only changes how any future gain is taxed, and it does so by making you carry single-stock risk to get there.

The cleanest way to see it: if your employer paid you $10,000 in cash instead, would you immediately buy $10,000 of company stock? For most people the honest answer is no. Holding vested RSUs is that same purchase, just automatic and unexamined.

There's also the concentration problem. Your salary, your benefits, your bonus, and your career trajectory already ride on this company. Adding your investment portfolio to the pile means a bad quarter at work can hit your paycheck and your net worth simultaneously.

Selling at vest and redirecting the proceeds into a diversified portfolio, or into whatever step you're on in your financial order of operations, is the boring but often correct default.

When are some other considerations?

  • Your company is private. Most private-company RSUs are "double-trigger"; they don't become taxable at time-based vesting, only when a liquidity event like an IPO or acquisition also occurs. Your tax timeline is out of your hands until then.
  • You're near a bracket boundary. A large vest can push you into a higher bracket, affect Roth IRA eligibility, or trigger the additional Medicare tax above $200,000 if you're approaching Medicare age. Worth modeling in a big year.

  • You're subject to trading windows or blackout periods. Many employees can only sell during open windows. A 10b5-1 plan, which schedules sales in advance, solves this and removes the emotion from the decision. 
  • You have unvested shares and a job offer. Unvested RSUs are forfeited when you leave. Their value is real leverage in negotiating a signing bonus or replacement grant.

The bottom line

RSUs are simpler than they look, but the simplicity hides one expensive trap: the 22% default withholding rarely matches what you owe. Know your vest dates, estimate your real tax rate on that income, close the gap before April, and be deliberate about how much company stock you keep.

If your annual vesting is starting to rival your salary, or you're navigating a private-company grant, an IPO, or a concentrated position you're not sure how to unwind, a conversation with a financial advisor may be the best next step.


When are RSUs taxed at vesting or at sale?

At vesting. The market value of the shares on the vest date becomes ordinary income on your W-2 that year, even if you don't sell. Selling later only affects tax on gains or losses that occur after the vest date.

Why do I owe taxes on RSUs if my company already sold shares to cover them?

Sell-to-cover typically withholds at the flat 22% federal supplemental rate. If your actual marginal rate is 24% to 35%, that withholding falls short and the balance is due at tax time.

How do I avoid a surprise tax bill from RSUs?

Add extra withholding on line 4(c) of your W-4, or make a quarterly estimated payment after a large vest. Paying 100% of last year's tax 110% if you earned over $150,000 could protect you from underpayment penalties.

Do RSUs count as income for a mortgage or loan?

Often yes, though lenders typically want a two-year history of vesting and may discount the value. Policies vary meaningfully between lenders, so ask early in the process.

What happens to my RSUs if I leave my job?

Vested shares are yours to keep. Unvested shares are almost always forfeited on your last day, which makes vest dates worth checking before you resign or accept an offer.